I wanted to write a long essay
about The Dark Knight and #20: The Dark Knight Rises. I would talk about
how they’re the only Batman movies which directly confront the inherently messy
contradictions of Batman the character and how those contradictions are
emblematic of America itself. Both have a bloody and messy origin story, crave stability, but never accept it. Both believe in law and order but are willing to go outside
the lines, as needed. Both believe in the People, but also the Individual. Both hold out certain ideals as unassailable, knowing
full well those ideals are unattainable, but worth holding onto nonetheless.
But instead of writing a long essay, I wrote this paragraph. Isn’t that better?
(Also, I really do have a job. And two kids.)
Anyway, maybe we need a few
hundred more viewings of each, to really get our thoughts together. In the
meantime, yeah, they’re good.
Final Verdict: KEEPER!
Also, here’s a rundown of our first 20 (yes, 20 already!) verdicts (links to past reviews on the right):
American Beauty vs. Amelie argument is explained very well, but I think I would keep both. I'll have to watch them both again because like you it's been a decade since I watched them. I would probably keep Amelie too, but I'll always have the memory of seeing American Beauty for the first time. Also like you the end always gets me. That's a tough one.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I think the Aviator is probably one of the best Scorsese over looked films. It also might be the fact that he comes full circle at the end. Beginning Howard Hughes being bathed by his mother and ending with it. I think that's much better than showing a rat on the balcony after everyone has had there brains blown out, but that's just me. Also I think Cate Blanchetts Kathryn Hepburn is spot on. Its more about personal preference than anything, I suppose
You're not wrong on either score. I was honestly kind of blown away at how good The Aviator is when I watched it again. But, I can't imagine popping it in to watch very often. If it's on AMC on lazy Sunday? Sure, I'll watch it.
Delete